Search for light sterile neutrinos with two neutrino beams at MicroBooNE

P P. Abratenko D D. Andrade Aldana L L. Arellano J J. Asaadi A A. Ashkenazi S S. Balasubramanian B B. Baller A A. Barnard G G. Barr D D. Barrow J J. Barrow V V. Basque J J. Bateman O O. Benevides Rodrigues S S. Berkman A A. Bhat M M. Bhattacharya M M. Bishai A A. Blake B B. Bogart T T. Bolton M M. B. Brunetti L L. Camilleri D D. Caratelli F F. Cavanna G G. Cerati A A. Chappell Y Y. Chen J J. M. Conrad M M. Convery L L. Cooper-Troendle J J. I. Crespo-Anadón R R. Cross M M. Del Tutto S S. R. Dennis P P. Detje R R. Diurba Z Z. Djurcic K K. Duffy S S. Dytman B B. Eberly P P. Englezos A A. Ereditato J J. J. Evans C C. Fang B B. T. Fleming W W. Foreman D D. Franco A A. P. Furmanski F F. Gao D D. Garcia-Gamez S S. Gardiner G G. Ge S S. Gollapinni E E. Gramellini P P. Green H H. Greenlee L L. Gu W W. Gu R R. Guenette P P. Guzowski L L. Hagaman M M. D. Handley O O. Hen C C. Hilgenberg G G. A. Horton-Smith A A. Hussain B B. Irwin M M. S. Ismail C C. James X X. Ji J J. H. Jo R R. A. Johnson Y Y.-J. Jwa D D. Kalra G G. Karagiorgi W W. Ketchum M M. Kirby T T. Kobilarcik N N. Lane J J.-Y. Li Y Y. Li K K. Lin B B. R. Littlejohn L L. Liu W W. C. Louis X X. Luo T T. Mahmud C C. Mariani D D. Marsden J J. Marshall N N. Martinez D D. A. Martinez Caicedo S S. Martynenko A A. Mastbaum I I. Mawby N N. McConkey L L. Mellet J J. Mendez J J. Micallef A A. Mogan T T. Mohayai M M. Mooney A A. F. Moor C C. D. Moore L L. Mora Lepin M M. M. Moudgalya S S. Mulleriababu D D. Naples A A. Navrer-Agasson N N. Nayak M M. Nebot-Guinot C C. Nguyen J J. Nowak N N. Oza O O. Palamara N N. Pallat V V. Paolone A A. Papadopoulou V V. Papavassiliou H H. B. Parkinson S S. F. Pate N N. Patel Z Z. Pavlovic E E. Piasetzky K K. Pletcher I I. Pophale X X. Qian J J. L. Raaf V V. Radeka A A. Rafique M M. Reggiani-Guzzo J J. Rodriguez Rondon M M. Rosenberg M M. Ross-Lonergan I I. Safa D D. W. Schmitz A A. Schukraft W W. Seligman M M. H. Shaevitz R R. Sharankova J J. Shi E E. L. Snider M M. Soderberg S S. Söldner-Rembold J J. Spitz M M. Stancari J J. St. John T T. Strauss A A. M. Szelc N N. Taniuchi K K. Terao C C. Thorpe D D. Torbunov D D. Totani M M. Toups A A. Trettin Y Y.-T. Tsai J J. Tyler M M. A. Uchida T T. Usher B B. Viren J J. Wang M M. Weber H H. Wei A A. J. White S S. Wolbers T T. Wongjirad K K. Wresilo W W. Wu E E. Yandel T T. Yang L L. E. Yates H H. W. Yu G G. P. Zeller J J. Zennamo C C. Zhang

Abstract

Abstract The existence of three distinct neutrino flavours, ν e , ν μ and ν τ , is a central tenet of the Standard Model of particle physics 1,2 . Quantum-mechanical interference can allow a neutrino of one initial flavour to be detected sometime later as a different flavour, a process called neutrino oscillation. Several anomalous observations inconsistent with this three-flavour picture have motivated the hypothesis that an additional neutrino state exists, which does not interact directly with matter, termed as ‘sterile’ neutrino, ν s (refs.  3–9 ). This includes anomalous observations from the Liquid Scintillator Neutrino Detector (LSND) 3 experiment and Mini-Booster Neutrino Experiment (MiniBooNE) 4,5 , consistent with ν μ  →  ν e transitions at a distance inconsistent with the three-neutrino picture. Here we use data obtained from the MicroBooNE liquid-argon time projection chamber 10 in two accelerator neutrino beams to exclude the single light sterile neutrino interpretation of the LSND and MiniBooNE anomalies at the 95% confidence level (CL). Moreover, we rule out a notable portion of the parameter space that could explain the gallium anomaly 6–8 . This is one of the first measurements to use two accelerator neutrino beams to break a degeneracy between ν e appearance and disappearance, which would otherwise weaken the sensitivity to the sterile neutrino hypothesis. We find no evidence for either ν μ  →  ν e flavour transitions or ν e disappearance that would indicate non-standard flavour oscillations. Our results indicate that previous anomalous observations consistent with ν μ  →  ν e transitions cannot be explained by introducing a single sterile neutrino state.

Article Details

Journal Nature
Volume / Issue Vol. 648, Issue 8092
Published December 04, 2025
Pages 64-69
ISSN 0028-0836
Publisher Nature Portfolio

Journal Info

Nature

Nature Portfolio

ISSN: 0028-0836 Health Sciences

Authors (177)

P

P. Abratenko

D

D. Andrade Aldana

L

L. Arellano

J

J. Asaadi

A

A. Ashkenazi

S

S. Balasubramanian

B

B. Baller

A

A. Barnard

G

G. Barr

D

D. Barrow

J

J. Barrow

V

V. Basque

J

J. Bateman

O

O. Benevides Rodrigues

S

S. Berkman

A

A. Bhat

M

M. Bhattacharya

M

M. Bishai

A

A. Blake

B

B. Bogart

T

T. Bolton

M

M. B. Brunetti

L

L. Camilleri

D

D. Caratelli

F

F. Cavanna

G

G. Cerati

A

A. Chappell

Y

Y. Chen

J

J. M. Conrad

M

M. Convery

L

L. Cooper-Troendle

J

J. I. Crespo-Anadón

R

R. Cross

M

M. Del Tutto

S

S. R. Dennis

P

P. Detje

R

R. Diurba

Z

Z. Djurcic

K

K. Duffy

S

S. Dytman

B

B. Eberly

P

P. Englezos

A

A. Ereditato

J

J. J. Evans

C

C. Fang

B

B. T. Fleming

W

W. Foreman

D

D. Franco

A

A. P. Furmanski

F

F. Gao

D

D. Garcia-Gamez

S

S. Gardiner

G

G. Ge

S

S. Gollapinni

E

E. Gramellini

P

P. Green

H

H. Greenlee

L

L. Gu

W

W. Gu

R

R. Guenette

P

P. Guzowski

L

L. Hagaman

M

M. D. Handley

O

O. Hen

C

C. Hilgenberg

G

G. A. Horton-Smith

A

A. Hussain

B

B. Irwin

M

M. S. Ismail

C

C. James

X

X. Ji

J

J. H. Jo

R

R. A. Johnson

Y

Y.-J. Jwa

D

D. Kalra

G

G. Karagiorgi

W

W. Ketchum

M

M. Kirby

T

T. Kobilarcik

N

N. Lane

J

J.-Y. Li

Y

Y. Li

K

K. Lin

B

B. R. Littlejohn

L

L. Liu

W

W. C. Louis

X

X. Luo

T

T. Mahmud

C

C. Mariani

D

D. Marsden

J

J. Marshall

N

N. Martinez

D

D. A. Martinez Caicedo

S

S. Martynenko

A

A. Mastbaum

I

I. Mawby

N

N. McConkey

L

L. Mellet

J

J. Mendez

J

J. Micallef

A

A. Mogan

T

T. Mohayai

M

M. Mooney

A

A. F. Moor

C

C. D. Moore

L

L. Mora Lepin

M

M. M. Moudgalya

S

S. Mulleriababu

D

D. Naples

A

A. Navrer-Agasson

N

N. Nayak

M

M. Nebot-Guinot

C

C. Nguyen

J

J. Nowak

N

N. Oza

O

O. Palamara

N

N. Pallat

V

V. Paolone

A

A. Papadopoulou

V

V. Papavassiliou

H

H. B. Parkinson

S

S. F. Pate

N

N. Patel

Z

Z. Pavlovic

E

E. Piasetzky

K

K. Pletcher

I

I. Pophale

X

X. Qian

J

J. L. Raaf

V

V. Radeka

A

A. Rafique

M

M. Reggiani-Guzzo

J

J. Rodriguez Rondon

M

M. Rosenberg

M

M. Ross-Lonergan

I

I. Safa

D

D. W. Schmitz

A

A. Schukraft

W

W. Seligman

M

M. H. Shaevitz

R

R. Sharankova

J

J. Shi

E

E. L. Snider

M

M. Soderberg

S

S. Söldner-Rembold

J

J. Spitz

M

M. Stancari

J

J. St. John

T

T. Strauss

A

A. M. Szelc

N

N. Taniuchi

K

K. Terao

C

C. Thorpe

D

D. Torbunov

D

D. Totani

M

M. Toups

A

A. Trettin

Y

Y.-T. Tsai

J

J. Tyler

M

M. A. Uchida

T

T. Usher

B

B. Viren

J

J. Wang

M

M. Weber

H

H. Wei

A

A. J. White

S

S. Wolbers

T

T. Wongjirad

K

K. Wresilo

W

W. Wu

E

E. Yandel

T

T. Yang

L

L. E. Yates

H

H. W. Yu

G

G. P. Zeller

J

J. Zennamo

C

C. Zhang