Performance evaluation of a reflex blood-based methylated ctDNA multi-cancer early detection test in individuals with obesity.
Abstract
100 Background: Obesity increases risk of 13 distinct cancers, most without screening programs, and collectively representing 40% of all annual US cancer diagnoses.With recent CDC data (2023) showing that obesity rates exceed 35% in 23 U.S. states, multi-cancer early detection (MCED) testing represents a unique opportunity to address a critical screening gap in this population. In this case-control study, we examined the performance of a reflex blood-based ctDNA methylation MCED test in individuals with obesity (BMI ≥ 30 kg/m 2 ), evaluating cancer-specific intrinsic accuracy (sensitivity) and positive predictive value (PPV). Methods: We analyzed peripheral blood samples (NCT05435066) from individuals with obesity, including 424 treatment-naïve cancer patients and 458 non-cancer controls, using a reflex test by Harbinger Health. The test system consists of a primary methylome profiling test optimized for high sensitivity (rule-out), followed by a confirmatory reflex analysis utilizing an expanded methylation panel designed to achieve high PPV (rule-in) and tissue of origin (TOO) classification. Test performance metrics were derived using 10-fold cross-validation with patient-level stratification. Overall cancer incidence in the obese population was estimated at 1.6%. Prospective PPV for each TOO readout was calculated using cancer-specific intrinsic accuracy estimated from the case-control study in combination with incidence values. Results: In this cohort (mean age 57.1 ± 13.4 years; 63.3% female; 67.8% White; 22.4%, Black or African American), the test achieved an overall 29.7% (95CI, 25.3-34.6) correct-TOO sensitivity (66.1% false negative, 4.2% incorrect TOO) at 98.9% (95CI, 97.6-99.6) specificity and 98.9% negative predictive value (95CI, 98.85,99.0). Among a subset of cancers associated with obesity, TOO-specific PPVs were: hepatobiliary (HB: liver, biliary duct; 100%; 95CI, ND), CRC (87.5; 95CI, 61.1-96.9), upper gastrointestinal (UGI; 81.8; CI95, 48.6-95.5), uterine (66.7%; 95CI, 26.5-91.7), pancreaticobiliary (PB: pancreas, gallbladder; 17.6%; 95CI 3.1-59.0). Corresponding cancer group sensitivities (early stage, I-II) were: HB 50.0 (35.1), CRC 51.9 (28.6), UGI 40.9 (9.1), uterine 8.5 (3.8), PB 56.5 (25.0). In a modeled cohort of 100,000 tested individuals, the expected TOO readout counts (correct case-type odds) were: 23 for HB (23:0), 60 for CRC (7:1), 42 for UGI (9:2), 23 for uterine (2:1), 279 for PB (1:5). Conclusions: Inindividuals with obesity at increased risk for multiple cancers, especially those lacking established screening guidelines, the reflex ctDNA methylation MCED test demonstrated clinically meaningful PPV and early-stage sensitivity for each cancer type. These results warrant prospective validation to assess the test’s clinical validity and utility in early-stage cancer detection in this high-risk population.
Article Details
Journal Info
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Authors (11)
Dax Kurbegov
HCA Healthcare Sarah Cannon Cancer Network, Nashville, TN
Elie Massaad
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
A. Gregory DiRienzo
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
Johanna B Withers
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
Dorna KashefHaghighi
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
Jocelyn Charlton
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
James Sun
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
Franziska Michor
Kieran Chacko
Harbinger Health, Cambridge, MA
Luke Roy George Pike
Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY
Hutan Ashrafian