Partner dependency alters patterns of coevolutionary selection in mutualisms

Abstract

Coevolution is a ubiquitous driver of diversification in both mutualistic and antagonistic interactions between species. In mutualisms, coevolution can result in trait complementarity between partners that facilitates their persistence. Despite its importance, most of what we know about coevolution in mutualism comes from obligate interactions, whereas we know comparatively little about facultative interactions, arguably the most common type of mutualism. To evaluate coevolutionary dynamics in facultative mutualism and test how it compares with obligate mutualisms, we used a synthetic yeast mutualism where the partners exchange essential nutrient resources. We manipulated mutualism dependency by controlling the availability of mutualistic resources in the environment and measured coevolution via time-shift assays and tracking the evolution of mutualistic traits over time. In addition, we genotyped the evolved and ancestral mutualists to test for differences in the strength of coevolutionary selection between facultative and obligate mutualisms. We found evidence of coevolution in both facultative and obligate mutualisms, but coevolution was weaker and slower in facultative mutualisms. We also found evidence for evolution of trait complementarity in obligate mutualisms but not in facultative mutualisms. Furthermore, obligate mutualists had more SNPs under positive selection than facultative mutualists. Together, these results provide strong evidence that mutualism dependency impacts both the strength of coevolution and the rate of trait evolution.