IL-4 epigenetically reprograms CART19-28ζ cells to drive dysfunction

Abstract

Abstract Recent studies have highlighted the important but pleiotropic role of IL-4 in response to chimeric antigen receptor T (CART) cell therapy. IL-4 was identified as a regulator of dysfunction in CD19-targeting CART cells with a CD28 costimulatory domain (CART19-28ζ) through a genome-wide CRISPR knockout screen as well as RNA and ATAC sequencing of baseline and exhausted healthy donor CART19-28ζ cells and pre-infusion CART19-28ζ cell products from responders and non-responders in the ZUMA-1 trial (Stewart et al, Nat Commun., 2024). However, interrogation of a single-cell atlas fromactivated pre-infusion CART cell products from patients with acute lymphoblastic leukemia revealed a beneficial role for IL-4 and other type 2 cytokines in the promotion of long-term response (Bai et al, Nature, 2024). In this report, we aim to further understand how IL-4 can be detrimental to CART cell therapy. To study the regulation of CART19-28ζ cells by IL-4, we performed RNA sequencing on CART19-28ζ cells that were stimulated with CD19+target cells in the presence of either 20 ng/mL hrIL-4 or diluent for 24 hours, one week, or two weeks in an in vitro model for exhaustion as previously described (Stewart et al, Nat Commun., 2024). We observed that hrIL-4 treatment drove the development of a distinct transcriptomic profile after chronic stimulation for one week (up genes = 3253 and down genes = 3645) or two weeks (up genes = 6435 and down genes = 6224) but not following 24 hours of activation (up genes = 0 and down genes = 0). Gene set enrichment analysis on the differentially expressed genes following two weeks of chronic stimulation showed that hrIL-4 treatment pushes CART cells to a more exhausted and less naïve phenotype (FDR = 0.015) and leads to a broad downregulation in cytokine signaling (FDR = 0.012). To investigate transcription factors associated with IL-4-induced CART cell dysfunction, we used BETA analysis with publicly available transcription factor binding sites for STAT6, GATA3, and EOMES and our differential expression data. EOMES (p = 0.039), but not STAT6 (p = 0.999) nor GATA3 (p = 0.999) significantly regulated the differentially expressed genes. In support of these findings, the addition of hrIL-4 also significantly upregulated EOMES expression after one (p < 0.0001) and two (p < 0.0001) weeks of chronic stimulation and downregulated the expression of TBX21 (p < 0.0001), a binding competitor of EOMES, following two weeks of chronic stimulation. To evaluate if EOMES is critical for IL-4-induced CART cell dysfunction, we treated either control or EOMES CRISPR knockdown CART cells with 20ng/mL hrIL-4 during chronic stimulation. EOMES knockdown reduced IL-4-induced CART19-28ζ cell dysfunction as seen by an increase in antigen-specific expansion (p = 0.046) and an increase in cytokine production including IL-2 (p < 0.0001), TNF-α (p = 0.006), and IFN-γ (p = 0.020). Having identified that EOMES is at least partially responsible for IL-4-induced CART cell dysfunction, we evaluated EOMES binding sites in human CART19-28ζ cells with CUT&RUN sequencing. Our analysis revealed EOMES binding at hypersensitivity site 2 (HS2) in the IL-4 locus which, in a previous study, was more accessible in both exhausted healthy donor CART19-28ζ cells and pre-infusion CART cell products from non-responders in the ZUMA-1 clinical trial (Stewart et al, Nat Commun., 2024). To determine how HS2 can impact CART cell functions, we generated CART19-28ζ cells from either wildtype (HS2+/+) or HS2-deleted (HS2-/-) murine T-cells and tested them in a syngeneic model of lymphoma generated by engrafting C57BL6 mice with luciferase+ TBL12 cells (1x106, tail vein injection on Day -3) following preconditioning (250mg/kg cyclophosphamide, intraperitoneal injection on Day -4). Following randomization of mice via tumor burden (n = 5 per group), mice were treated with either HS2+/+ or HS2-/- CART19-28ζ cells (1x106 cells, tail vein injection). In this model, HS2-/- CART cells showed enhanced expansion (p = 0.022), increased anti-tumor activity (p = 0.018), and improved overall survival (p = 0.003). Together, our study shows that IL-4 induces a distinct cellular fate in CART19-28ζ cells in the presence of chronic antigen-specific stimulation at least partially through the upregulation of EOMES. Further, the epigenetic regulation of CART cells by the IL-4 enhancer HS2 can significantly influence CART cell activity, and deletion of HS2 can improve CART cell therapy.