Development and validation of search hedges for Transgender and Gender Diverse (TGD) populations in Ovid MEDLINE and Ovid APA PsycInfo

Abstract

Introduction This paper describes the development and validation of highly sensitive search hedges for Ovid MEDLINE and Ovid APA PsycInfo that effectively identify literature on transgender and gender diverse (TGD) populations. Methods Two librarians developed the search hedges using relevant keywords and controlled vocabulary terms, building on previous work on identifying transgender populations in evidence synthesis. The hedges were tested and refined to capture diverse and expansive gender identities across cultures and disciplines. The hedges were validated for sensitivity using a gold standard set of 144 articles from the Knowsy portal of evidence syntheses tagged as Two-Spirit, transgender, or gender non-binary. To assess precision an international research team of subject experts independently screened a randomized sample of search results in a two-stage screening process with an additional screener resolving disputes. Results The final search hedges demonstrated 100% sensitivity in both MEDLINE and APA PsycInfo, identifying all 144 relevant articles from the Knowsy gold standard set. The MEDLINE search hedge achieved a 71% precision, and the APA PsycInfo hedge achieved a 67% precision. These results balance comprehensive retrieval while minimizing non-relevant articles for an efficient screening process. Conclusions These search hedges in MEDLINE and APA PsycInfo are valuable tools for researchers and librarians to more effectively identify literature on TGD populations. These tools will be crucial for ongoing work in addressing gaps in research and health disparities faced by TGD populations and will be particularly valuable for researchers conducting evidence synthesis projects related to this population.