ctDNA kinetics throughout first-line AI and palbociclib using a tumor-informed structural variant-based ctDNA assay: Retrospective analysis of PADA-1 samples.
Abstract
3050 Background: With standard assays (Limit of Detection [LoD95] at or >100 PPM), most patients with ER+/HER2- mBC show ctDNA "clearance" within a few weeks after initiating first- line AI+CDK4/6i, with ctDNA becoming detectable again only at or shortly before progression. To gain a more comprehensive view of ctDNA kinetics in response to therapy, we analyzed serial plasma samples from PADA-1 using a tumor-informed assay with a 100-1,000-fold higher sensitivity (LoD95 <10PPM). Methods: PADA-1 allowed the collection of plasma at baseline and every two months during first-line AI+palbociclib (PAL). A total of 489 serial plasma samples from 45 patients in PADA-1 were analyzed using an ultrasensitive structural variant-based ctDNA assay. WGS was performed on tumor material from archival primary or metastatic biopsies, and personalized multiplex dPCR assays tracking up to 16 somatic structural variants were used for ctDNA monitoring. Results: At baseline, before AI+PAL start, ctDNA was detected in N=40/41 evaluable patients (98%). ctDNA remained detectable in 381/489 (78%) samples during therapy. ctDNA was persistently detectable and quantifiable (i.e. detected at all timepoints) throughout first-line therapy in most initially positive patients (24/40, 60%). With this ultra-sensitive assay, we report, for the first time, that ctDNA follows a recurrent kinetic pattern: (1) a steep decrease during the first 6 months of treatment, (2) a nadir reached at 6–12 months, and (3) a continuous increase until radiological disease progression (or discontinuation of follow-up). In some patients (15/40, 38%), ctDNA became undetectable at some point during therapy despite the high sensitivity of the assay, with sustained ctDNA clearance associated with no risk of impending tumor progression. Conclusions: Serial analyses with a highly sensitive ctDNA test uncover the molecular trajectory of tumor response to first line AI+PAL. The presence of an early ctDNA nadir, followed with a later slow and continuous increase of ctDNA, prior to radiological progression, highlights the dynamic nature of ER+ HER2- mBC response to therapy. This approach can complement imaging-based disease monitoring, extends the clinical utility of ctDNA monitoring beyond individual mutations, and opens new perspectives of therapeutic interventions and treatment adaptation. Clinical trial information: NCT03079011 .
Article Details
Journal Info
Journal of Clinical Oncology
Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
Authors (16)
Luc Cabel
Veronique D'hondt
Institut du Cancer de Montpellier (ICM), Montpellier, France
Thomas Bachelot
Patrick Soulie
ICO Paul Papin, Angers, France
Chantal Bernard-Marty
Clinique Pasteur ONCOSUD, Toulouse, France
Pascal Boucher
R&D Unicancer, French Breast Cancer Intergroup, Paris, France
Clara Guyonneau
R&D Unicancer, French Breast Cancer Intergroup, Paris, France
Anne Pradines
Claudius Regaud Institute, Toulouse, France
Völundur Hafstad
SAGA Diagnostics, Morrisville, NC
Céline Callens
Sofia Birkealv
SAGA Diagnostics, Lund, Sweden
Miguel Alcaide Torres
SAGA Diagnostics, Morrisville, NC
Jennifer Yen
SAGA Diagnostics, Morrisville, NC
Karen Howarth
SAGA Diagnostics, Morrisville, NC
Frederique Berger
Institut Curie, Biostatistics Unit, Paris, France
François Clément Bidard