Circulating tumor DNA refines risk stratification of neoadjuvant therapy-resistant breast tumors

M Mark Jesus M. Magbanua N Nayelis A. Manon D Denise M. Wolf S Samuel Rivero-Hinojosa Z Ziad Ahmed R Rosalyn W. Sayaman A Antony Tin D Derrick Renner E Ekaterina Kalashnikova L Lamorna Brown-Swigart G Gillian L. Hirst C Christina Yau W Wen Li C Claudine Isaacs R Rebecca A. Shatsky A Amy S. Clark A Alexandra Zimmer A Amy L. Delson A Angel Rodriguez M Minetta C. Liu P Paula R. Pohlmann L Laura J. Esserman H Hope S. Rugo (City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center, Duarte, CA) A Angela DeMichele (University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia) L Laura van ‘t Veer

Abstract

Abstract Early-stage breast cancers resistant to neoadjuvant therapy (NAT), characterized by high residual cancer burden (RCB) after treatment, have an increased risk of metastatic recurrence. Here, we show that circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) detected using a tumor-informed test (1) can improve risk stratification of patients with NAT-resistant tumors (RCB-II/RCB-III) and (2) predict response to NAT. Stratification using ctDNA status at pretreatment or post-NAT and ctDNA dynamics identified NAT-resistant tumors with a significantly decreased risk of metastatic recurrence. ctDNA clearance as early as week 3 across receptor subtypes predicted favorable responses to NAT, including immunotherapies. Interestingly, less than a fifth of patients with NAT-resistant tumors were ctDNA-positive post-NAT. Serial mutation profiling of NAT-resistant tumors revealed that patient-specific ctDNA assay variants remained detectable over time, including in tumors of patients ctDNA-negative post-NAT. Refining risk stratification for NAT-resistant tumors using ctDNA and understanding ctDNA shedding in these tumors could guide treatment decisions to prevent or delay metastatic recurrence.

Article Details

Volume / Issue Vol. 16, Issue 1
Published December 09, 2025
ISSN 2041-1723
Publisher Nature Portfolio

Journal Info

Nature Communications

Nature Portfolio

ISSN: 2041-1723 Open Access Life Sciences

Authors (25)

M

Mark Jesus M. Magbanua

N

Nayelis A. Manon

D

Denise M. Wolf

S

Samuel Rivero-Hinojosa

Z

Ziad Ahmed

R

Rosalyn W. Sayaman

A

Antony Tin

D

Derrick Renner

E

Ekaterina Kalashnikova

L

Lamorna Brown-Swigart

G

Gillian L. Hirst

C

Christina Yau

W

Wen Li

C

Claudine Isaacs

R

Rebecca A. Shatsky

A

Amy S. Clark

A

Alexandra Zimmer

A

Amy L. Delson

A

Angel Rodriguez

M

Minetta C. Liu

P

Paula R. Pohlmann

L

Laura J. Esserman

H

Hope S. Rugo

City of Hope Comprehensive Cancer Center, Duarte, CA

A

Angela DeMichele

University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine, Philadelphia

L

Laura van ‘t Veer